Victoria Beckham's gray cashmere dress: Who wore it better?

Victoria Beckham originally wore the gray cashmere dress (together with her sky-high Loubs and oversized sunnies) from her Victoria Beckham Collection back in July in London. Super Elle Macpherson then decided to show up on the NYC set of The Beautiful Life wearing the same dress - lower, pointier pumps and equally oversized sunnies.

Both ladies have a smoking hot figure, but only one can be crowned Queen! Who's it gonna be?